A husband’s obsessive desire for a child leads to an unexpected manifestation of his yearning in a nightmarish short story about fatherhood dreams by New York Times bestselling author Joe Hill.

I think Joe Hill does a great job of building the atmosphere of the woods. His choice of words invoke a sense of eerie isolation for the reader. It feels as though the woods had a mind of its own. I liked the concept and introduction of the early settlers of the town. I wished Hill had put more development into explaining their backstory and purpose.
I found that Willy wasn’t very compelling as the main protagonist and the pacing for the short story started off quite slow. It picked up a bit during the midpoint. The story would’ve benefitted from a balance of alternating between Willy and Marianne’s perspectives. Especially since Marianne had more depth as a character and provided much needed rationality to Willy’s obsession clouded-mind.
This was my first experience with an Amazon original story and it was entertaining, if not a little bit predictable. I was however slightly underwhelmed at the open ending as it left me with many unanswered questions. I am still interested to read more from Joe Hill in the future, I have very high hopes for NOS4A2. I probably will continue with the other stories in this collection.